The representation of justice in India is undergoing a significant transformation. The iconic image of Lady Justice, traditionally depicted with a blindfold to signify impartiality, has been reinterpreted, challenging centuries of legal symbolism. The Supreme Court of India recently unveiled a new statue of Lady Justice, one without the traditional blindfold. This change reflects a powerful message: justice is not blind, but rather it sees clearly and judges fairly, ensuring that the law is applied equally to all, as per the Constitution.
Who is the Lady of Justice?
While Lady Justice has been a familiar figure in Indian courthouses for decades, the concept doesn't have roots in Indian mythology or ancient texts. In fact, the representation of Lady Justice comes from Western traditions, particularly Greco-Roman culture. Historically, she is a symbol of fairness, balance, and the moral duty of the law. But why was there a need to change her image in India? What message does this new statue convey? And how does it differ from the colonial interpretation of justice that was imposed during British rule?
The History Behind the Symbolism of Lady Justice
- No Mention in Indian Legal History: There is no reference to Lady Justice in India’s Constitution or legal framework. The figure of Lady Justice as we know it has no direct link to Indian legal traditions. In response to an inquiry under the Right to Information (RTI) Act, the Supreme Court confirmed that there is no formal mention of the Lady Justice symbol in any Supreme Court document. It’s a borrowed concept, widely adopted during British colonial rule.
- Colonial Legacy: The figure of Lady Justice was introduced to India during the British era as part of the colonial legal system. However, some argue that this image represents a foreign approach to justice, one that may not necessarily align with India’s own legal and moral philosophies.
- Greek and Roman Roots: The figure of Lady Justice originates from ancient Greece and Rome. In Greek mythology, she is known as Themis, the goddess of justice and order. She is often depicted holding scales in one hand to represent the weighing of evidence, and a sword in the other to symbolize the swift power of justice. However, in the Greco-Roman tradition, Themis and her Roman counterpart, Justitia, were not always blindfolded.
- The Blindfold: The idea of a blindfold came later in European art, symbolizing impartiality—that justice does not see the identity of the accused or the accuser and treats all equally. But this concept has been increasingly debated in modern contexts. Does justice need to be blind to be fair? Or should it be aware of the nuances and realities of each case?
The Evolution of Lady Justice in India
 |
| Screen shot image from X |
The decision to alter the statue’s appearance in the Supreme Court is a symbolic shift away from colonial-era thinking. Removing the blindfold and replacing the sword with the Constitution sends a clear message: India’s justice system is evolving to reflect modern values and the unique needs of its diverse population.
- From Colonial Symbolism to Indian Thought: The modern interpretation of Lady Justice now aligns more with Indian values of justice and fairness. By replacing the sword with a copy of the Constitution, the statue emphasizes that justice in India is grounded in the highest law of the land. This change highlights the focus on Constitutional supremacy, replacing punitive power with the idea of justice as a guiding force based on reason and rights.
- The Removal of the Blindfold: The removal of the blindfold is perhaps the most significant change. This symbolizes that justice is not blind but conscious of the socio-political realities of India. The statue reflects that the law is not detached from society but is instead aware of its responsibilities. Justice, according to this new vision, should not be indifferent but actively engaged in understanding the context and circumstances of each case, offering remedies that are both fair and just.
- Balancing Scales and Constitution: The new statue still holds scales, symbolizing the weighing of evidence and fairness. However, the sword has been replaced with the Constitution, reinforcing that India's justice system is bound by the values of democracy, liberty, equality, and fraternity enshrined in the document. This shift shows a move towards a justice system that emphasizes rule of law and fundamental rights over punishment.
The Global Origins of Lady Justice
While the Lady of Justice is now a fixture in Indian courtrooms, her origin traces back to ancient civilizations long before her modern interpretation.
- Greek and Roman Traditions: As mentioned, Lady Justice comes from the ancient goddess Themis in Greek mythology, and Justitia in Roman culture. Both were seen as symbols of morality and judicial fairness. In ancient Greece, Themis was seen as an oracle who could see into the future, advising the gods on justice. In Rome, Justitia became associated with the civic duty of fairness and morality in governance.
- Egyptian Influence: Even before the Greco-Roman depictions, ancient Egypt had a similar figure. The goddess Ma’at was regarded as the personification of truth, balance, and cosmic order. Egyptians believed that the souls of the dead were judged based on the principles of Ma’at, showing that the concept of justice being tied to morality and fairness is an ancient and universal idea.
- Medieval and Modern Adaptations: Over time, as societies evolved, so did the figure of Lady Justice. The blindfold, which became a common feature in the Middle Ages, was meant to show that justice was unbiased. However, modern legal systems, including India’s, are moving towards a more conscious and aware system of justice.
India’s Modern Justice System and the New Symbolism
In recent years, India has made significant strides in reforming its legal system to be more in tune with the needs of its citizens. The introduction of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC) replacements—Indian Justice Code and Indian Civil Security Code—are part of this broader effort to modernize the legal framework.
- Reforms and New Legal Codes: These new laws are aimed at delivering justice to all, with a focus on rehabilitation and fairness over mere punishment. The new codes emphasize justice over retribution, in line with the principles of modern democracy.
- The Changing Vision of Justice: As India continues to reform its legal system, the shift in symbolism from a blindfolded Lady Justice to one holding the Constitution reflects a broader change in how justice is perceived and delivered. It is no longer about blind punishment but about ensuring that justice is fair, balanced, and rooted in constitutional values.
Conclusion
The new statue of Lady Justice in India's Supreme Court represents a significant shift in the country's legal philosophy. By removing the blindfold and emphasizing the Constitution, the new imagery of Lady Justice reflects a justice system that is conscious, aware, and guided by the rule of law. It marks a move away from colonial legal traditions towards a uniquely Indian interpretation of justice—one that is fair, inclusive, and firmly rooted in the values of the Constitution.