In a recent report released by SEBI (Securities and Exchange Board of India), an alarming statistic was revealed that sends a clear message to retail traders venturing into the futures and options (F&O) market: over 93% of retail traders consistently lose money. This data, covering the period from FY22 to FY24, paints a sobering picture for small-scale investors looking for quick gains in the F&O segment.
In light of these findings, it’s crucial for both new and seasoned retail investors to understand the complexities of F&O trading, the associated risks, and the reasons why such a large portion of participants are unable to succeed.
The Harsh Reality of F&O Losses
F&O trading has grown in popularity among retail investors due to its promise of high returns in short time frames. However, the SEBI report reveals that 93 out of 100 retail traders in this segment end up losing money, with only a mere 7.2% making any profit over the three-year period from FY22 to FY24. Even more stark is the fact that only 1% of traders made over ₹1 lakh annually.
This continues a worrying trend: an earlier study from SEBI covering FY19 to FY22 had shown that 89% of retail traders lost money. This means that despite increased access to information, online trading platforms, and market data, retail investors' financial outcomes are not improving.
You may also like these article:
India's Retail Inflation Stays Below 4% for the Second Consecutive Month in August
Tata Motors Share Price Decline: A Detailed Analysis
IPO Frenzy: A Week of High Momentum in India’s Primary Market with 13 IPOs and 8 Listings
Reliance Industries Approves 1:1 Bonus Share Issue, Strengthens Commitment to Shareholder Value
Raymond Lifestyle Shares Debut at ₹3,000, Hit Lower Circuit on Listing Day: All You Need to Know
Who Profits from F&O?
While retail traders struggle, other market players like proprietary traders and foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) are reaping significant rewards. In fact, algo traders – those who use automated software to execute trades at high speed – dominate the profit-making sector. The study notes that 97% of FPIs' profits and 96% of proprietary traders' profits came from algo trading in FY24.
The automation of trading has introduced an entirely new competitive edge that retail investors find hard to match. As these entities deploy cutting-edge technology and complex algorithms, retail traders, most of whom rely on personal judgment or basic market research, are often at a severe disadvantage.
The Financial Cost of Losses
The financial impact on retail investors is immense. According to SEBI’s findings, the average loss per retail trader in the F&O segment was approximately ₹2 lakh, with a total loss of ₹1.8 lakh crore spread across 1.1 crore retail traders over the three-year period. The top 3.5% of loss-makers, accounting for around 4 lakh traders, incurred an average loss of ₹28 lakh each.
The psychological toll of such significant financial losses cannot be ignored either. Traders who face repeated losses may experience stress, frustration, and pressure to recoup their money, which can lead to further reckless trading behavior and deepening losses.
The Growing Presence of Young Traders
One concerning trend highlighted in the report is the sharp rise in young traders, especially those under 30 years of age. Their participation in F&O trading surged from 31% in FY23 to 43% in FY24. Unfortunately, 93% of these younger traders incurred losses, a rate even higher than the overall average.
This growing demographic of young, tech-savvy individuals may be lured into F&O trading by its perceived profitability, but the risks they face are clearly underappreciated. Without sufficient experience or knowledge, they are particularly vulnerable to market volatility.
Why Do Retail Traders Lose Money in F&O?
There are several reasons why retail traders struggle in F&O trading:
- Lack of Knowledge: F&O markets are highly complex and involve significant leverage. Many retail traders do not fully understand the intricacies of how futures and options work, leading to poor decision-making.
- High Transaction Costs: Even small-scale traders face high transaction costs, which can eat into any potential profits. Between brokerage fees, exchange fees, and taxes, retail traders are often left with thinner margins than they realize.
- Leverage Risk: F&O trading allows traders to take large positions with a relatively small capital base, thanks to leverage. However, leverage is a double-edged sword. While it can magnify gains, it can just as easily amplify losses, leading to significant financial damage.
- Emotional Trading: Many retail investors trade based on emotions rather than a well-thought-out strategy. Fear of missing out (FOMO), greed, or panic often drives decision-making, leading to impulsive trades that end in losses.
- Lack of Tools and Automation: Unlike proprietary traders and FPIs who have access to advanced algorithmic trading tools, retail traders typically operate manually. This puts them at a severe disadvantage when it comes to speed and efficiency in executing trades.
The Regulatory Push for Change
The consistent loss rates among retail traders have raised red flags within the regulatory framework. SEBI has already indicated its intent to reform the F&O market to protect retail investors, focusing on margin requirements, contract values, and ensuring greater transparency in trading practices.
These measures aim to prevent retail traders from taking excessive risks without fully understanding the consequences. However, until more concrete regulations are implemented, retail traders must exercise caution and adopt more informed trading practices.
What Can Retail Traders Do to Succeed?
Despite the challenging statistics, retail traders can still find ways to minimize losses and improve their chances of success in the F&O market. Here are a few strategies:
- Education: Before diving into F&O trading, it is essential to understand the mechanics of futures and options, how leverage works, and the risks involved. Take time to study the market thoroughly.
- Risk Management: Develop a solid risk management plan, including setting strict stop-loss levels, limiting the use of leverage, and not risking more than a small portion of your trading capital on any single trade.
- Avoid Emotional Trading: Stick to a well-researched trading strategy rather than reacting emotionally to market movements. Avoid trading based on tips, rumors, or the fear of missing out.
- Use Demo Accounts: Practice trading in a demo account before committing real money. This allows you to develop and test your strategy without financial risk.
- Stay Updated on Regulations: Keep track of SEBI’s upcoming regulatory changes in the F&O market. These could impact margin requirements and trading costs, so staying informed can help you adjust your strategy accordingly.
Conclusion: Tread Carefully in the F&O Market
F&O trading may offer opportunities for profits, but as SEBI’s study clearly shows, it is a treacherous path for the majority of retail investors. With 93% of participants losing money and the dominance of algo traders and institutional players, retail traders must approach the market with caution and awareness.
Education, risk management, and a disciplined trading approach are essential to survive and potentially succeed in this challenging environment. With regulatory reforms on the horizon, the future of F&O trading may change, but the key takeaway remains the same: trading without knowledge is gambling, and the house usually wins.